Watch this guide as a video
I want to share Saloni's story with you because it is one of the most honest, practical accounts of an O-1 journey I have come across. Saloni is an MBA graduate with about a decade in tech marketing — mostly helping startups launch and scale across South Asia and Africa. She moved to the US in January 2024 on an F-2 dependent visa while her husband finished his master's degree at Georgia Tech. Within a few months, she realised the F-2 was far more restrictive than she had expected — not just in terms of paid work, but even volunteering for companies or projects that are normally compensated. That realisation pushed her to start exploring other paths.
Why the O-1 visa made sense when other options did not
Saloni looked at three realistic routes. First, waiting for her husband to get an H-1B job and then applying for an H-4 — but that would have taken at least two years, possibly more. Second, enrolling in another degree programme to get back on an F-1 — but after nine years of high-impact work and an MBA, she had no interest in going back to study. Third, the O-1. It was intimidating at first. She told me, 'I don't have a PhD, I'm not from an Ivy university, I don't have published research papers — there's no way I'm getting this.' She also described having significant imposter syndrome. But she paused, looked into it properly, and realised that a few things she had done were beginning to line up with the criteria.
What appealed to her most about the O-1 was freedom. Her goal was never specifically America — it was the ability to work anywhere, based on her skills, without being tied to a single employer. The O-1 gives you exactly that. It is a three-year work visa that you can extend indefinitely in one-year or three-year increments, and it does not chain you to a sponsoring company in the same way an H-1B does.
What the O-1 criteria actually means in practice
The O-1 is designed for people who are in the top one percent of their profession — anywhere in the world, in any field. USCIS lists eight criteria, and you need to meet at least three of them. However, I always tell applicants to aim for four to five. The reason is straightforward: if an officer does not fully understand one of your criteria and issues a Request for Evidence (RFE), you want enough backup criteria that your petition still holds up. An RFE is where USCIS comes back and asks you to provide more evidence for a specific point. The ideal situation is a petition so clean and well-structured that it is understood on the first read.
The eight criteria cover things like: receiving significant awards or recognition, holding a critical role at an organisation, earning a high salary relative to peers, being part of exclusive professional memberships, judging others' work in your field, making original contributions, being featured in media, and having expert letters from recognised figures in your profession. The tricky part — and Saloni spent two months working through this herself — is that the criteria are intentionally grey. What 'critical role' means for a researcher is completely different from what it means for a founder or a marketer. You have to interpret each criterion through the lens of your own field.
How Saloni built her case — criterion by criterion
Criterion 1: Critical Role
This was her clearest starting point. She had been Director of Marketing at multiple startups, leading teams and owning the launch and scalability metrics for major products. Importantly, these roles were in India and Africa — not the US. If you are worried that your experience outside the US will not count, Saloni's case is a direct answer to that concern: it absolutely can. She also obtained a letter from a former CEO (from a role she held in 2018 — six years before her petition) confirming the scope of her work and the fact that she personally owned the North Star metrics for the company. The letter was drafted by Saloni and stamped by the CEO. That is a common and entirely legitimate approach.
Criterion 2: High Salary
This one required a smart benchmarking strategy. The challenge was that Saloni had reached Director level earlier in her career than most people do — typically that title comes with 15 to 20 years of experience, and those professionals earn more. The approach she and her lawyer landed on was to benchmark her salary against peers with the same years of experience (eight to nine years) from similar educational backgrounds, rather than against everyone who holds a Director title. If you are filing for high salary, the key question is not 'how do I compare to everyone with my job title?' but rather 'how do I compare to people with my same profile?' This was based on her salary from the job she held in 2023, just before moving to the US — and yes, your past salary counts even when you are not currently working.
Criterion 3: Exclusive Membership
While on her F-2, Saloni got absorbed in the startup ecosystem around Georgia Tech and started developing a health tech idea rooted in her personal experiences with medical systems in both India and the US. She applied to incubators globally (deliberately avoiding US-based ones because she was unsure how her F-2 visa would interact with them), and in July 2024 she was accepted by Antler — a highly selective global incubator. For her cohort, Antler had received around 11,000 applications and accepted 86 founders. She was able to obtain Antler's presentation deck showing their selection criteria, the backgrounds of founders accepted (including people from Google and Jio), and those acceptance statistics. That documentation is what made this criterion provable.
Criterion 4: Original Contribution
Want personalized feedback on your answers?
Shachi does 1-on-1 mock interviews — get real-time coaching before your consulate visit.
Book a Mock InterviewHere is the one that surprised even Saloni herself. Back in 2014, when she was 19, she had co-authored a book on economics with Dr. Swati Mahajan, who writes books for UPSC aspirants. Saloni's name appeared on the book as a co-author. She had never really thought of it as a credential — she had done it at 19, wasn't even on LinkedIn at the time, and just moved on with her life. But when she mentioned it to her lawyers, they confirmed it could qualify under original contribution because her name was on a published work. The lesson here: go back through your entire career history, even things you did a decade ago and never considered remarkable. If your name is on something — a publication, a product, a co-authored piece — it may count.
Criterion 5: Judging Others' Work
Wanting to have a fifth criterion as a safety net, Saloni asked around in her network in Atlanta and the Bay Area and found opportunities to judge hackathons. She specifically evaluated the marketing and go-to-market strategies of startup teams — an angle that is often overlooked in hackathons, which tend to focus on the technical side. If you are a non-technical professional looking for judging opportunities, that gap is often exactly where you can contribute.
Criterion 6: Media Mentions
In 2020, a media house based in Bangalore had featured Saloni in a video about her marketing career and approach to launching products. She had not thought much of it at the time. When she looked more carefully, the media house had around half a million YouTube subscribers — which gave it enough reach to be considered significant coverage. She also had a couple of podcast appearances. These became supporting evidence rather than primary criteria, but they reinforced the overall narrative of her petition.
The expert recommendation letter — and why it matters
Separate from the eight criteria, an O-1 petition is strengthened significantly by an expert recommendation letter from someone recognised in your field. This does not have to be someone you have worked with directly — it can be someone who knows your work from a distance. In Saloni's case, her former boss at the company she worked for before moving to the US was the CMO, based in Los Angeles. She reached out, explained what she was doing, and her ex-boss agreed to write the letter. What this letter does is provide a credible voice from within your industry saying: yes, this person is as extraordinary as they claim to be.
How Saloni filed — through her own company
One important structural point: Saloni did not have a US employer to sponsor her. So she set up her own company in the US in October 2024 and petitioned through it. The company petitioned her as its CEO. This is a legitimate route for founders and independent professionals — your own entity can be your O-1 petitioner. It does require that you handle the compliance and tax setup correctly, but it removes the dependency on finding an external sponsor.
The most important lessons from Saloni's journey
A few things stand out to me from everything Saloni shared, and I think they apply to almost every O-1 applicant I work with.
First, most people start at one to one-and-a-half criteria — and that is not a reason to give up, it is just the starting point. The process is about identifying what you have and then strategically building toward the remaining criteria you need. Saloni went from one-and-a-half criteria in May 2024 to six argued criteria by the time she filed.
Second, the criteria are grey, not black and white. What 'critical role' or 'high salary' means depends entirely on your field and your career trajectory. Do not read the USCIS definition and immediately assume it does not apply to you — work through what it means in the context of your specific profession.
Third, your past experience counts — including things from years ago and work done outside the US. Saloni used a role from 2018, a book she co-authored in 2014, and a media feature from 2020. None of it was recent, none of it was American, and all of it contributed to an approved petition.
Fourth, document things as you go. Saloni's one regret was not documenting her Antler journey in real time. She was focused on building her product and did not think about saving evidence. Fortunately, Antler had a detailed deck she could obtain after the fact — but that may not always be the case. If you are building something, joining something, or doing something that could serve as O-1 evidence, keep a record of it now.
Fifth, go back through your entire history and look for things you have undervalued. A co-authored book you wrote at 19. A media feature you forgot about. A hackathon you judged. These are real credentials — they just need to be surfaced, contextualised, and presented correctly.
Need help with your visa preparation?
Have questions after reading this guide? I’m happy to help.
Chat with Shachi on WhatsAppNext steps
Continue your preparation with these resources.
Related Guides
How did a doctor build her O-1A visa profile from scratch — and get approved?
Dr. Manjula Kumari had no idea the O-1A visa existed until a friend looked at her profile and told her she was already partway there. What followed was a multi-year journey of building evidence, navigating contradictory advice, and ultimately securing approval across six O-1A criteria — and her story has lessons for anyone wondering whether their own profile is strong enough.
Is my profile good enough for an O-1 visa?
Most people who get their O-1 visa approved started with one nagging feeling: that they were not good enough yet. If that is where you are right now, you are closer than you think — and three questions can show you exactly where to begin.
How do I choose the right university for my F1 visa approval?
The university you choose is the very first thing a visa officer notices about you — and in many cases I have seen, students were refused without a single question being asked simply because their university choice raised red flags. Here is the exact three-step process I walk every student through to make sure their university selection works for them, not against them.
